Should I grade my comic book or keep it raw?

Should I grade my comic book or keep it raw?

Choose a comic for grading by deciding how you want to enjoy it, identifying the exact edition and inspecting the whole copy. We walk through a two-copy example and explain what to send for a UK submission enquiry.

Written by Fantasy Road

Explore UK CGC submissions Read FAQs
Should I grade my comic book or keep it raw?
Decide whether access to the inside pages matters.
Identify the edition before comparing copies.
Ask for a submission quote based on your own book.

Picture the comic you would rescue first if the spare room ceiling sprang a leak. Now ask yourself what you love about it. If the answer is the double-page spread halfway through, putting it in a sealed holder presents a fairly immediate design flaw.

What do you want from this particular copy?

CGC grading gives you an independent assessment of condition and a sealed holder for the book. That suits a collector who wants to display a favourite cover, document a family piece or keep a standout issue separately. If you pass it round the kitchen table every Christmas, a fresh bag and board might give you more pleasure. Sentimental value counts. It just answers a different question from resale value.

Two copies, two sensible answers

Say you own two copies of the same issue. One has a bright cover and a shallow bend. The other has your dad’s name inside and the crossword completed with impressive confidence. The first might suit grading. The second might be the one you actually want to keep within reach. Before deciding, check the printing and edition inside each copy. Similar covers can conceal different books.

Give the book a gentle once-over

Use ordinary light for the front and back, then low side light for dents. Look at the spine and any loose pieces without opening a fragile book flat. Make a note of an autograph, missing coupon or old repair. Those details help us discuss suitability and whether optional preparation would address anything you can see.

Get a quote you can actually use

Send the issue, printing if known, clear photographs and a sentence about your aim. Ask for the cost of the route you want, including return delivery. If you would still enjoy owning the slab a grade lower than you hoped, that tells you rather more than an optimistic listing ever will.

How CGC grades a comic

Got a particular comic in mind?

Tell us what it is and why you are considering grading it.

Explore UK CGC submissions

Frequently asked questions

Can I read a comic after CGC grading?

The pages sit inside a sealed holder. Keep a reading copy or collected edition if you want regular access to the story.

Should I grade a comic with sentimental value?

It can make sense if an independent condition record and display holder matter to you. Decide how you want to handle and enjoy it first.

Can Fantasy Road predict my CGC grade from photos?

Photos help us discuss suitability, visible defects and preparation. CGC assigns the grade after examining the physical book.

Related articles

What photos should I send to make sure I get the best offer possible for my comics?How Much Are My Comics Worth? The Ultimate UK Guide to Valuing & Selling Comic Books (2026)

Comments

Leave a comment

You need an account to join the conversation.

Log in Create account
Fantasy Road Logo - We buy any comic books

Fantasy Road Ltd 2026 ©️ Registered in England and Wales (Company Number: 13507222). Registered office: 167-169 Great Portland Street, London, England, W1W 5PF